Captain Tony's Pizza - Reviews

This restaurant used to be good years ago in the early 2000s. Like a lot of things, it has gone downhill. I went there recently and ordered chicken parmesan. I...

The bathroom is absolutely disgusting, the sink, the walls, the urinal, and the toilet all gross. The door looks as if it will crack when I shut the door. And t...

I love the pizza! Glad to see this place is still around after all these years. Says a lot

Excellent and delicious pizza, strongly recommend, and the service was great!

They never have delivery driver every time I walk in they have attitude as if they don’t want to be bothered sorry that you guys are lazy teenagers

Great food and a good value pizza is always consistently good Chicken Parm sandwich is great enough for Teo

Fast and good. Perfect pickup after a Guardians game and a rapid ride back to the car. Right there on the square. Will be back.

Oookay. I rate STRICTLY ON TASTE! The ingredients are QUALITY. I prefer a greasy, tasty top quality pizza. I was impressed. The mozzarella sticks were VERY good...

Their food is decent but not as good as it was some years ago when it was under different management. It's a good go 2 place when you don't want to cook.

Worst experience ever! There were 2 roaches crawling on the floor. The man who I believe is the boss or manger told me I was lying and tried to kick me out befo...

Captain Tony’s is a Shaker Square dining favorite of mine. Their deep dish pizza , salads

This review is not based on a recent visit, but I was recently thinking about Captain Tony's gyro pizza. It has been years since ordering from Captain Tony's, b...

My husband and I have been frequenting Captain Tony's since he first moved here 6 years ago, and we've always been happy with their food and service. Delivery s...

Great food and a good value Pizza is always consistently good Chicken parm sandwich is large enough for teo

This is a lovely establishment, the workers are nice and the prices are easy on the wallet compared to other pizza establishments, my favorite item is the XL pe...

Oookay. I rate STRICTLY ON TASTE! The ingredients are QUALITY. I prefer a greasy, tasty top quality pizza. I was impressed. The mozzarella sticks were VERY good...

My first time eating this pizza, and it beat all the other pizza I have tried. Gold star. Fast delivery and friendly driver...Very Delicious!!