Artie's Steak Seafood

This place is in city island. Table for 2 spent about $139 total. The food was okay. Rice was a little salty. Drink wasn't bad, not too strong. There is a parking space. It has and inside and outside dining. It's nice and quiet inside. It gives you a little candlelight feeling without the candles. Give meals enough to share for 2. Baked Clams were delicious. I had center pork chop. It made me left like I was getting steak. They did a great job with it.

I'm very disappointed. This place was highly recommended by a local. Unfortunately, the fried food was overcooked. The dark brown scallops, clams shrimp and fish were hard and left a bad taste in my mouth. The corn on the cob was tasty but not hot. The only saving grace was the French fries. I tried my best but couldn't eat it. The server took it back and brought me a new plate that looked good, was cooked properly but wasn't very tasty. The server apologized but the owner or manager never came to the table.. I won't be going back.

I could not let this day pass without writing this review. My Fiancé andI had the pleasure of visiting Artie’s today. THE SERVICE WAS PHENOMENAL. The food…… ALSO PHENOMENAL. We had the greatest time! Everyone was kind and happy and took their time with us. We had lamb chops, Octopus, and baked clams for appetizers. The ribeye and the shrimp and lobster fettuccine alfredo were both cooked to perfection. Honestly, I will continue to come here as it came highly recommended and exceeded all our expectations. Thank you to the staff at Arties!

The food and atmosphere were really good but the service was exceptional. The server, the bar tender, and even the boss was impressive with a welcoming hospitality. It is now a go to spot when I visit City Island.Food: 4/5

I had the jerk-seasoned mahi mahi, very tasty and moist.Friends all had shellfish, mussels or calamari, they all seemed to thoroughly enjoy it all.Hubby got the individual pizza with meatballs and really liked it.