Hoosier Mama Pie Company - Reviews

I wanted to gatekeep this hidden spot but the pie and atmosphere are simply too good!

[At pet store on same block as Hoosier. Employee A: “I’m going to Hoosier Mama. Do you want anything?” Employee B: “I was just there.” Me: “I’m going there now....

I love it. Delicious breakfast sandwiches and hand pies. The menu varies by season sometimes. But the selection is great, plenty of indoor and outdoor seating....

Cute and quaint. Delicious baked goods. Great fresh coffee. Chill vibes.

Love this place...sugar creme and chocolate chess are my favorites

I've been so excited to try the cake since I saw it on TV for a Chicago Pier competition. We had the chocolate cream cake and it was delicious. The cream was li...

Since the day Paula Haney started selling cakes at Green City Farmers Market, she has sold the best cakes in Chicago. The brick and mortar situation in the Ukra...

Delicious flavors. We had the mushroom goat cheese handpis, the Spinat Artichoke Galette and the chicken stuff. The dough is fabulous and the fillings incredibl...

Omg. What can I say? I thought I was a fan of chocolate cake until I had their fruits. My husband and I have 3 slices of cake, a cookie and a handpie (lamb and...

A true blast from the past vibe! The interior feels like being transported into a diner from the 50s. The seating area and shop in general is not too big, and t...

Wife wanted lemon meringue pie for mother's day and sent me into the city with a mission to find the best one.

This review is more so for the pie book - I've gone pie crazyAfter tasting a slice of their chocolate chess pie and banana cream pie I was sold.

I was very disappointed with my pie from hereI love pies and I've been wanting to come here for so longI may have hyped myself up a little too much.