Chatham Penny Candy Store - Reviews

cute little store but its not a penny. candy is good and is definitely cheap!

Staff was nice but i wish that it was still a penny store. I am old as dirt and remember the days that things were a penny. nice town and wish that it could exc...

Says that its a PENNY store but its not. overpriced and cash only.

Stopped in for some ice cream and got candy for the kiddos too. Cute shop, and a must stop when walking on main street.

Fudge was very underbaked and soft. Felt like it was melted, almost like play dough.

Small town candy shop with great fudge and some ice selection. The owner was very nice. Only cash.

I'm glad we came over this sweet place! You have amazing ice cream along with a beautiful selection of sweets and fudge

Nice business and LOTS to choose from. No bad prices. Taffy is really delicious.

Fun little spot from Main Street in downtown Chatham where you can get all kinds of candy and saltwater taffy through the pound. Bring the whole family here and...

Had ice cream cones. Flavors were delicious, service was excellent. The variety of penny candy was incredible!