Peter Shields Inn - Reviews

We went to PSI for a milestone birthday, which we noted when we made the reservation. Despite a busy evening, I was a bit disappointed when we were seated in th...

Wonderful food, great service and a warm and inviting environment.

50th Anniversary Celebration that became a wonderful dinning experience.

Love the food, people, atmosphere. The staff were polite and very well trained in the art of fine dining. I would continue to recommend this experience to all w...

Thanksgiving. For $95 a head not great. Cold bread, had the Turkey dinner, no cranberry sauce? Really? I don’t think there’s a shortage of cranberry sauce it’s...

We have been dining at Peter Shields for many years. This year it was a complete disappointment. Poor service by a waitress whose experience was in a diner. Her...

We've been going to Cape May for years. There are many incredible restaurants, unfortunately Peter Shields did not live up to the hype. Service was poor. The wa...

Lovely all across the board. Music. Service is always excellent. Good with the new chef is still fine. Tonight the branzino was especially good.

Had a lovely dinner with my wife while on vacation!

Brought my family of seven here for dinner, the service was great, the appetizers were great, the dinner was great the only thing that was not great for some su...

What an outstanding place and the food was absolutely awesome

Wonderful dining experience! Delicious food! Excellent Service! Dining Ambience with live piano player providing relaxing background music!

Great experience ! Christoph was outstanding again as he was 16 years ago. Thanks again to all. Josephine William M. East Brunswick NJ

Excellent NY Strip, very good fish, salads and deserts. Dinner at Peter Shields never disappoints. Piano music throughout the dinner is very nice as well.

Our dinner experience was great. Our waiter was very attentive, and of course, the piano music is a wonderful addition to the ambiance. We hope the restaurant w...

My husband and I have been celebrating special occasions at PSI for years and have always loved it. This last time we were celebrating our wedding anniversary a...

Beautiful turn-of-the-century B&B Restaurant located on Beach Ave in Cape May's NJ. Would highly recommend! Ask for Sean; friendly, attentive while not rushing...

PSI is a beautiful venue. We had a party of 6 and everyone's meal was exceptional. The piano certainly added to the ambiance. We were celebrating a few end of t...

Everything was outstanding. The only gripe was we had a 7:00 reservation and waited about 20 minutes to be seated. They had a small wedding party there so that...

Everything was fantastic. From the amazing appearance of the building walking up to the main entrance to the elegant setting inside. My wife and I had a wonderf...

The service was excellent, food presentation and quality were outstanding. Our waiter Peter was a delight Service: 5 Location: 5 Hotel highlights: Luxury, Great...

I have long wanted to experience dinner at PSI, it more than met my high expectations. A fantastic special occasion dinner. Service: 5 Location: 5

Highly recommend for small weddings! Our wedding dinner at PSI was AMAZING. The food was AMAZING. The service was AMAZING. Everyone was so kind and really went...

Beautiful and elegant atmosphere. Sean, our waiter was amazing. Piano is a great touch and not too loud , perfect way to complete our fabulous meal. Will defini...

Had a great late lunch here with friends food was immaculate and was shocked by some of the dishes so delicious Rooms: 5 Service: 5 Location: 5

We were staying at the inn and also had dinner there. We started with oysters as an appetizer and they were perfect. For dinner, we had the lobster thermidor an...

Can I give this restaurant 10 stars?!?! My parents and I had the most amazing meal here yesterday. I have been coming to Cape May my whole life and I can't beli...

The staff is excellent and the restaurant offers a variety of delicious options. We make sure to visit at least three times a year, traveling all the way from n...