Peace Pie - Reviews

This place is amazing. I thought six dollars for ice sandwich would be too much, but I must say every bite was worth it. Rich, creamy, fresh and tasty. I couldn...

We make sure to go here multiple times during our stays in Cape May. Very friendly owner and a great selection of items! Our favorites are Salted caramel browni...

Absolutely amazing!!! Got the coconut cream one, now I want to try every flavor.

Yum! We tried seven different flavors and they were all amazing!

In the Cape May area for the day and wanted to find an ice rink to take the family. Very glad I found this little place that only specializes in ice bread. Not...

The ice cream sandwiches are good and there are lots of flavors to choose from. $8 for a sandwich which is a bit pricy, but I guess by being a seasonal business...

Very cute shop with many options. Unfortunately there were no vegan ice cream options. Would love to see this added to the menu and be able to come back and sup...

Great selection of really good ice cream sandwiches and a cool vibe

A great sweet shop in Cape May. The worker is SOO nice, the ice cream sandwiches are so delicious and beautiful crafted. There is no wait (even for your food to...

Why have we not tried this sooner? This was one of the best deserts I've had! It was delicious, easy to eat, fairly priced and no wait.

Greet ice cream stop. Fast to get food and well run. Menu can be tricky to find here?s Oct 22s list.

Stopped by Peace pie for dessert while in cape may and wow, so glad I did because it did not disappoint! Took me a while to figure out which one I wanted MOST b...

Glad I got mine to go. These are so tasty if I had eaten mine at the shop, I would have gone back up multiple times for more. The great number of menu choices a...

So I had 1, and then proceeded to order another and then another. These chocolate shortbread cookies are crispy, buttery good! Ice cream flavor and texture is s...

Lots of flavors is the only nice thing I can say. 2 stars for a good concept and poor execution. She handing me a frozen solid pre fabbed sandwich, it took abou...