Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies - Reviews

The best there is! Picked up a pie to bring to a family gathering, and enjoyed some “Swingles” on site. Highly recommend

The absolute best key lime pie, me and my family have ever had. I have no more words we will be back to buy more.

Really nice treat on a summer's day...enjoy taking the kids there, then a little walk around Red Hook...

Amazing pie. I have had key lime pie inthe Florida keys and this is better.

My daughter and I drive about an hour from Long Island to Red Hook Brooklyn for Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie. It's GREAT Key Lime pie!

The personal pies were a perfect size and delicious! More of a key lime custard filling.

Delicious! Pies are pricey but high quality and worth it. There's no indoor seating, so come prepared to take it home or eat on the picnic tables out front (or...

The raspberry swingle is always a perfect treat enjoyed in the adjacent waterside park on a hot summer day.Pro tip: if you can be patient, let the swingle tempe...

The swingle is great! Key lime pie covered in chocolate on a stick! So inventive and delicious! Watch the sunset while enjoying Key West flavors in Red Hook

Amazing! Got the Classic…key lime pie in a stick covered with dark chocolate