Sgt. Pepperoni S - Reviews

Have been calling since 6:15 pm it is now 7:00. Hmmmm would love to try their pizza BUT phone is continually busy. Guess they don’t need the business that bad

The pizza was not bad. We prefer a thinner, softer crust, but it was a little too thick and very tough. More sauce would have been better also.

Delicious pizza, I was surprised when I saw the staff tossing the dough. Most pizza places serve frozen pre-made crusts. We ordered the double cheese, double cr...

Best pizza ever, really. I want to take them home with me!

delicious pizza! like an old-fashioned family lead pizzeria. everything was perfect. I know pizza and that was excellent.

Solid pizza and pleasantly surprised by crust, sauce and taste.

Really good tavern style pizza here! Really tasty chewy crust. We got the works! Highly recommend.

I was craving pizza yesterday and Sgt. Pepperoni's really delivered! Very delicious! Highly recommend.

Despite the limited options for pizza in the area, this restaurant exceeded expectations. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and was pleasantly surprised by how good i...

Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30

This review is not for the pizza or service it's about the fact that they make no effort to change their hours of operation on Google which is super easy to do)...

They made a pizza for me that wasn't on the menu! Chicken Bacon Ranch and it was incredible!!!

The Godmother's Pizza was amazing! We bought a large, ate 1/2 and ate the rest for lunch the next day. Not many eating choices in Bayfield now that Maggie's is...

The pizza at this restaurant was absolutely delicious! The crust had the perfect balance between crunchiness and chewiness. The cheese, toppings, and sauce were...

I had a great experience with the large vegetable pizza at this restaurant. It was square-cut, which made it perfect for sharing with a group. The pizza had a g...

I ordered the Summer Special at this restaurant and it was delicious. They warned me that my pizza might take 40-45 minutes due to high demand, but it arrived m...