Poppy's - Reviews

Best banana ice cream ice ever had!!!! This place is a hidden gem!

Last night daughter and I were in Barnegat Light and decided to try Poppys. It is a cute ice cream place but the line to get served was long for a Tuesday night...

I waited in line for days. The days turned to weeks. The scooper, while distracted, made it turn to months. But, it tasted nice.

Worth the wait— the staff handled our large group of 11 so well and the ice cream was delicious! Get the nutter butter flavor!

Ice cream is good, but not worth the 40 minute wait in line

We love this place and have enjoyed it a couple times this week before the crowds come. Everyone there is friendly and helpful and the ice cream tastes great!

The perfect ice cream stop in LBI! It's the only one in Barnegat Bay, so it definitely gets a bit crowded. They have amazing flavors to choose from as well of l...

This place can't be beat! #1 ice cream on LBI, hands down (and the lines outside prove it) Trust me though, the line moves fast, and the eats are worth the wait...