New York Pizza - Reviews

First pizza in Aspen and it was great! The prices are great and staff are very friendly. It was just me so I chose a pizza by the slice, pepperoni and sausage a...

Pizza by the slice or whole pizza. They were so busy, but still got to our order pretty quick. Good deals on NY style pizzas, with their huge XL Pizza being the...

If you 're looking for terrible service, mediocre food, and a surly and dismissive staff, then this is the place for you.We ordered two small pizzas for our kid...

This is genuinely the saddest excuse for pizza. It used to be great for the 20 years I’ve been coming here. I would avoid this place at all costs. The pizza is...

This is a perennial locals hang out for Aspen. Today I had the barbecue chicken with jalapeño pizza slice, it’s amazing. Highly recommend this restaurant. You c...

Our preferred pizza stop when in Aspen. Very good pizza, the prices are reasonable. These slices are huge, and very quick service. All pizzas hand tossed, salad...

My husband and I stopped here for lunch and we were happy to have chosen this place . It’s a small cozy place with the owners who warmly welcomed and served fre...

A small, cozy eatery for a quick lunch, casual dinner or late night snack (they close at 2am). I have so many good memories waiting in line to get a slice of pi...

Solid pizza joint in the middle of Aspen. I got a giant works slice with a beer. Slightly higher price than expected but i guess that's Aspen. They have some dr...

This place was the bomb, it's on the second floor which is actually nice for a great view. The pizza was great. We had four people and got 2 pies, an XL with Pe...

Horrible service. Everyone there was rude but one guy behind the counter was over the top a jerk. Ordered two cheese slices. He took them out of the oven...

Had a very long travel day and didn't make it to Aspen until 10:30 and New York Pizza was one of the few places thankfully still open so we ran in. They...

Very solid pizza. Plenty of sauce and tasty, crisp crust. Beer selection a bit limited (no IPA? , but open late. Folks behind the counter super nice and...