Donatellos Pizza - Arkville

I ordered a pizza that had a large hole in it (3 inches in 2 separate slices). I brought it back and they didn't apologize. I have been a loyal customer for nearly 20 years, long before the current owners took over. I will now be looking for a new pizza place to frequent.

This used to be my favorite pizza spot, but lately the taste has been off. It seems to have a strange chlorine-like flavor that makes it taste terrible. I'm not sure what has changed, but the dough tastes really bad now. It's just not the same as it used to be.

The restaurant may not have the best ambiance, but the pizza is exceptional. It is the top choice in the area.

Great food, bad parking! that's the only reason I don't have 5 stars!

This place is one of my favorites! Affordable pricing, large dishes and the staff are always very welcoming.