Bortell's - Reviews

Absolutely gem of the island! I will say this, we ordered pizza then brought it to the beach. It was THE BEST pizza I've had on the island and top 5 favorite pi...

Price per person: $20–30 Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza

Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Meatball Banana Peppers, Chicken Wings

Horrible service, the gentleman who is the host has a horrible attitude. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

I shared with Eli (bartender) about another patron who was creepy, much older and WAY too touchy during my time here (i excused myself and didn’t return). He st...

Limited menu, dirty and bad service. Wouldn't recommend and won't return. Perhaps if all you want is a beer.

My wife I had a fun time at Bortell's. The staff was great, the food was good, but not fantastic. We enjoyed ourselves very much.

Service was excellent. The burgers were fresh and made to order. Overall a great vibe on a hot summer night!

Food and service provided by Eli was amazing! Came here for a girls trip and we will come back before we leave!

We came in after dinner one evening and saw this is more of a local dive bar atmosphere. A lot of locals were hanging out and everyone was super friendly....

Get the chicken thumbs they’re huge!