Amagansett Seafood Store - Reviews

Mikes seafood is unparalleled. I may never have had a better lobster roll. And the ceviche and smoked bass are gourmet! Perhaps most of all, Mike is fun, charmi...

Rude ! No regard for the costumer! Refused to help ! Might have been intoxicated?

Amagansett seafood is absolutely the best seafood market in all of Long Island. The owner, Mike makes the experience one that you will never forget. Not only do...

No exaggeration, I’m OBSESSED with their food. Everything i’ve tried is delicious. And the owner and staff are the best people you could ever hope to meet. I on...

Ask for price up front and be sure and count your change!

I went in right before closing on a holiday weekend and it was quite a scene. The owner was hugging regulars like they were family. Then he excused himself to t...

Mike is special, he knows everything about fish and by choosing Chelsea, nothing about football. Love this guy and the shop. Hidden treasure is salmon curry.

Tried this place for the first time a few months ago and when I went back to the area, I had to go back. It is hands down the best lobster roll in the world. So...

ZERO STARS!! Stay away!! The owner was rushing me off the phone when trying to order steamed lobsters. When i went to pick them up he was drinking beer and doin...

Friendly staff, delicious fresh food, best lobster roll I have ever had can't wait to come back

Mikes seafood is the freshest. His scallops ceviche unparalleled as well as his collection of salads. Finally he is a wonderfully fun and friendly soul who love...

Simply the best seafood store in the Hamptons.The owner, Mike, is wonderfully knowledgeable about all the fish and shellfish he sells. He goes out of his way to...

Came in for a $35+ lobster roll which ended up just a lobster salad roll. Wish it was warm with butter but I didn’t ask so maybe they do it? Owner was there and...

Amagansett seafood is absolutely the best seafood market in all of Long Island.The owner, Mike makes the experience one that you will never forget. Not only doe...

No exaggeration, I’m OBSESSED with their food. Everything i’ve tried is delicious. And the owner and staff are the best people you could ever hope to meet. I on...

Beautiful small seafood shop that carries a good selection of prepared salads, soup, fresh fish, live lobster. Owner is really nice. I have the lobster salad......

Food is always delicious and extremely fresh! Since I was a toddler, I have been loyal customers for 19 years, the quality is always amazing! Customer service i...

Such a great spot for food and craic . Best find on the Hampton’s. Mike is a mad man

This is definitely a two-part review... there is food, and then there is hospitality. In this case they are inseparable, but if you have not yet experienced the...

Excellent cod shrimp for lunch!! Burn with taste! Crab soup amazing! Thank you.