The Athenian Cafe - Reviews

If you want authentic Greek food this is as close as you will get. As a younger woman I remember when this place first opened in the Juniata section of town. So...

Got take out, food was decent. Steak kabobs, I wasn't impressed with. Greek chicken salad was legit tho.

Casey was the absolute best. The atmosphere is fresh and clean. Would definitely recommend eating here.

The feta stuffed falafel is absolutely delicious! ?

Delicious food waitresses were very helpful and knowledgeable

Best Greek food around! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Aegean Platter, Greek B...

Nice place, good food. Reasonable prices. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Falafel, Hummus, Lamb Gyro Wrap Parking space So...

Love this place and the food is delicious. I’ve had the Moussaka, Spanakopita, Lamb Gyro and Chicken Kabob platter. Everything is prepared well and service is p...

Been on my bucket list to eat here, I was not disappointed! Food and portions were excellent. I have no idea how the hell to pronounce what I ate, let’s just sa...

This place has amazing food. We all had original gyros and side Greek salads. They were very filling and tasted amazing. We also opted to get stuffed grape leav...

We are vegetarian so we didn't quite know where to go for lunch as there are not too many options in this city but I'm glad we went here! Our waitress was so he...

Best gyros around hands down. Not only is the food amazing but the staff was wonderful. I locked my keys in the car and they were kind enough to let me hang out...

Amazing food. Best gyros I have had in a long time and all the other food was amazing. The servers were the most kind people ever and went above and beyond to h...

Best Gyros in town! (because they're the only gyros in town; but still very tasty!

Really good gyros, I had the lamb. It came fully loaded with all the fixings. Great flavor on a warm soft gyro bread. From first to last bite you'll be pleased....

Always enjoy our food and service. Would be nice to have music in background, would be more relaxing and not hearing other people's conversations.

Excellent service! Food was spot on and large portions. Got the lamb gyros and they were well sauced and spiced. Would definitely go back

We drive over an hour just to go here. It's mine hubby's special little place. Went last night for my birthday. Absolutely love the ladies that work there. Alwa...

Excellent food and friendly staff. I have had their pastiche, spanakopita, and baklava. All were incredible. I also think they have the best hamburgers and chee...

Excellent Greek food! I get the grape leaves frequently for lunch, and baklava as a sweet treat. Highly recommended!

Have been eating at and getting takeout from this restaurant since it opened at the original location in Whenwood many years ago. Pretty sure we've had the same...