New York Pizzeria - Reviews

Drove from Binghamton to get a Christen salad and marinated chicken sub. Worth the time and gas. Excellent value.

El'Presidente should visit THATS how good steak sandwich is off the chain..riggies a solid 7.7..PORTNOY where are you?

We’ve had Pizza’s from all over the Utica area. I’ll say that we are fortunate to have many good Pizza places to choose from. New York Pizzeria is hands down th...

I grew up eating Frank and Rosa's pizza. I always have to stop in and get a pie or at least a couple slices when I'm in town. It's always as good as I remember...

The best pizza around! The huge wings and their everything sauce is the best! Super friendly staff!

Best chicken riggies and pizza. Lorenzo is the man! Always great food and a friendly family! Enjoy doing business with them and they sure as hell appreciate the...

We have enjoyed the Waterville NY Pizzeria as long as I can remember. The food is consistently good, and the price is reasonable. Their antipasto is the best ar...

I've never been disappointed by anything ever ordered from New York Pizzeria. Their pasta dinners are to die for and the portion sizes are generous- I highly re...

It's a nice place to eat. Very friendly service with a beautiful atmosphere. If you're in the Waterville area It's worth the visit. The food is great. Kid-frien...

Some of the best pizza in the area always great and the owners always make sure they take care of you!